Inshore Paddle Tail Wars -Volume I

Inshore Paddle Tail Wars -Volume I

Happy Monday Spacefish!

Today I am diving into the world of tackle reviews, with a Volume I installment of the “Great Inshore Paddle Tail Wars.” I have been able to fish more recently, and I thought with the extra time on the water, this would be a great time to experiment with 2 different paddle tails, and do a head to head comparison.

Why These Two Brands?

Recently, I found myself in Academy getting some stuff before I smoked a bunch of pork and turkey for Thanksgiving. I decided to browse the fishing section while there, and for some reason was drawn to the Down South Lures paddle tails. I had been using DOA a lot recently and thought that this would be a good time to test the Down South against DOA and see which one I liked better.

I felt like both offered a good price point, and value, and they were similar sized. For this experiment, I used the “Purple Reign” color for Down South, and the Silver Rush/Silver Mullet color for DOA. I used a ⅛ oz chartreuse jig for DOA. This is the same DOA combo I have been catching a lot of fish on recently. For Down South, I used the Z-Man Trout Eye jig, which I already had in my tackle box, since Academy does not sell Down South’s jig heads. I use the neon/chartreuse eye in 3/16 oz. I wanted them to be as similar as possible, and since the Down South bait is not as dense, I went with a slightly heavier jig.

Areas Fished

Last week I wrote about my trips to Snag Harbor, which is across the Lagoon from John Jorgensen’s Landing in Grant. I also took an afternoon trip on Turkey Creek launching out of Pollak Park, from 2-5:30ish. I felt like these two locations gave me an all around inshore variety, as typically most inshore trips for me are either fishing mangroves in the IRL or fishing one of the brackish tributaries that flow into the IRL.

DOA CAL Shad

The DOA CAL Shad is one of those timeless 3″ paddletails that just flat-out produces across the Indian River Lagoon. It’s a simple, durable soft plastic that works on the flats, around mangroves, under docks, or anywhere you’ve got bait pushing around. The CAL is known for its clean, consistent thump—just enough vibration to get noticed without overpowering fish that are acting finicky or spooky.
With a huge range of classic DOA colors, it’s easy to match water clarity or mimic whatever the trout, redfish, or snook are feeding on. The CAL fishes equally well on a jighead or weedless rig, and its compact profile matches the smaller forage we see most of the year. These baits are affordable and dependable. A pack won’t break the bank, and DOA’s Florida-made plastics hold up to multiple fish before tearing.

Bottom line: the DOA CAL Shad is a no-frills, highly effective inshore paddletail that stays in my box because it’s tough, versatile, and flat-out catches fish when conditions get finicky.
This paddle tail swimbait comes in a pack of 12 baits. Price Range: $3.83-$4.79 at Academy Sports (depending on clearance status). It is by far the most affordable, household name brand paddle tail on the market. But despite its affordability it’s a proven fish catcher! Also, the DOA headquarters and factory are located just south of us, in Stuart, all of their products are made right here in Florida.

I have used the DOA CAL Shad way more over the years, I’ve caught just about anything that swims using it including Tarpon. Recently I caught lots of Trout, over a dozen Snook, and a handful of Redfish, Ladyfish and Mangrove Snapper. I have also caught some quality sized Snook, and Redfish over the years. While I didn’t catch any bigs on these trips recently, this bait can easily produce quality fish as well. It’s a great bait to work along the bottom for bigger fish.

DOA CAL - Snook

DOA CAL - Snook

DOA Cal - IRL Turkey Creek Trout

DOA Cal - IRL Turkey Creek Trout

DOA CAL Mangrove Snapper

DOA CAL Mangrove Snapper

Down South Lures – Burner Shad

The Down South Lure Burner Shad is a 3.5″ soft plastic swimbait that shines on the flats, along mangrove shorelines, and near other types of natural structure & cover. This bait has gained a reputation for getting bites when fish are acting picky. Its hybrid tail gives it that perfect subtle “swim on the fall” action—great for fooling inshore gamefish when they’re just following and not committing. It comes in both some really interesting color patterns (29 total) that allow the angler to find the right color for the water quality they are in . Between the lifelike movement and sharp paint jobs, this bait does a great job imitating small forage in pressured areas.

This paddle tail swimbait comes in a pack of 7 baits. Price Range: $5.19-$6.49 at Academy (depending on clearance status). While not as affordable as the DOA CAL Shads, these baits are unique, and also made in the US, with the company, and their manufacturing being based in Texas. This bait has an interesting design, it features a chunky body with a skinny tail, that gives the bait a ton of action without causing too much vibration, but it really shines on “the fall”.

On my recent trips experimenting with this bait, I was able to catch a good number of fish in a variety of species. I caught a bunch of Trout, a decent amount of Snook, a few Largemouth Bass further back into Turkey Creek, and I even got 2 Tarpon hook ups as well, but they both came off. I did cheat the experiment, and went with a 3/0, ⅛ oz Owner Twistlock hook when fishing further back in Turkey Creek, due to the amount of submerged rocks & timber, and getting snagged several times.

Down South Lures - Snag Harbor Snook

Down South Lures - Snag Harbor Snook

Down South Lures - Snag Harbor Trout

Down South Lures - Snag Harbor Trout

Down South Lures - Turkey Creek Bass

Down South Lures - Turkey Creek Bass

Compare, Contrast, and Rate

I cannot declare a winner between the two, and to be honest, as I continue to do this series, my mission will not be to declare a winner. Beauty is very much in the eye of the beholder, and my goal is to give a good description, and a personal, opinion-based rating.

DOA CAL – PRO’s

For DOA CAL, this bait is dense for a smaller swimbait, weighing ⅕ of an ounce on its own, and paired with a ⅛ oz jig, can be cast really far. Of the two baits, it is the most efficient for casting. It also skips extremely well on a jig. This is a major pro for the DOA CAL.

Another big plus is the affordability of the bait. As far as fish catching, this bait really shines at generating lots of bites, and bringing in quantity and variety. It also comes in a super wide array of colors, and with the affordability factor, it’s easy to load up on a wide variety of colors to bring along without taking out a second mortgage.

DOA CAL – CON’s

This bait is probably my least favorite paddle tail on the market to rig on a weedless hook. With it being smaller, and pretty dense, it’s not the best to rig weedless. It’s possible on a 3/0 Owner Twistlock but the bait slips a lot and I find myself constantly having to fix it back up.

Now, I think in many ways the next thing I am about to say is also a strength, but the DOA CAL Shad doesn’t have a ton of action, it’s a dense, streamlined bait, so you have to move it at a decent speed to get the tail to wiggle, and even then, it does not give off much wobble or vibration. However, in the shallow, calmer waters of the Indian River Lagoon system, too much action and vibration can at times be a hindrance as well.

DOA CAL – Rating

When factoring in all of the pro’s and con’s, I give this bait a rating of a 9.2/10

Down South Lures, Burner Shad – Pro’s

This bait has great action, while also being subtle. Not an easy feat to pull off for a soft-plastic! It’s because of the unique design, with the skinny tail, and the small paddle. It looks super lifelike in the water, and it can be retrieved at a very slow speed and still give a good swimming action.

It also has lifelike tail action on the fall, which makes it a true Trout killer! But it also can be effective for Snook & Tarpon due to the lifelike swimming quality, and the ability to be effective on a slow-roll retrieve. It also comes in a decently affordable price point. The color options are less than half of that offered by DOA, but the Purple Reign color is really nice, and they have other options as well that look intriguing.

Down South Lures, Burner Shad – Con’s

I have two major cons. The first is it’s not very dense, which means it does not cast super far, you may have to go with a heavier jig to really bomb casts out there. Also, compared to the DOA CAL it does not skip nearly as well with a jighead.

The other con I have is that even when rigged weedless it does not skip as well as other baits in the 3.5 size, because it does not have as much surface area. Also with the skinny tail, it does not push as much water, or cause as much vibration if fishing in areas with choppy water.

Down South Lures, Burner Shad – Rating

When factoring in all of the pros and cons, I give this bait a rating of a 7.6/10

Conclusion

I really like both of these baits, if I had to choose a “winner” I could not at this moment. I believe they both offer strengths, and some weaknesses, but they both flat out get bit, and at the end of the day, that is what we are all after!

kayaks by bo One thing that I believe is much more important than what you throw, is where you throw. The ability to get to the right areas and not spook fish is so much more important that what is tied to the end of your leader. With Christmas around the corner, and all of us being in shopping mode, now is the perfect time to drop into Kayaks By Bo, and check out their inventory. Not only do they have lots of great kayak options, but all of the accessories, and gear you could possibly want as well!

Thanks for taking the time to read this report, I hope you have an awesome week, and get a chance to get on the water a stick some fish! Stay safe, be happy, and have a joyful Christmas season. Until next time!